Knowledge

Do You Really Need That X-Ray or MRI? What Scans Can and Can't Tell You

November 13, 2026
Do You Really Need That X-Ray or MRI? What Scans Can and Can't Tell You

By Dr. Brett Poniros, DC, CSCS

Medical imaging like MRIs and X-rays can be valuable for diagnosing injuries and guiding treatment. But for athletes and active people, these tests can sometimes create more confusion than clarity.

When a report mentions terms like "disc bulge," "degenerative disc disease," "minor arthritis," or "rotator cuff tear," it's easy to feel concerned. But just because something appears on a scan doesn't necessarily mean it's the cause of your pain or that you need aggressive treatment.

What Scans Often Show in People Without Pain

Imaging results should always be considered alongside your symptoms and a physical exam. Here's why some common findings aren't always a major concern.

Disc bulges and degeneration. A systematic review of 33 studies covering 3,110 people without back pain found that disc degeneration showed up on imaging in 37% of 20-year-olds and 96% of 80-year-olds, and disc bulges in 30% of 20-year-olds and 84% of 80-year-olds. The authors concluded that many of these degenerative features are likely part of normal aging and unassociated with pain.[1] Despite the intimidating name, degenerative disc disease is a lot like getting wrinkles: it's common, and it doesn't automatically mean pain or limited movement.

Rotator cuff changes. A pooled analysis of 30 studies and 6,112 shoulders found that rotator cuff abnormalities on imaging rose from about 10% in people 20 and younger to about 62% in people 80 and older, with a similar age-related rise whether or not people had symptoms. The authors describe this degeneration as a common aspect of normal aging.[2] That covers abnormalities of all sizes, not only full tears, but the takeaway holds: strength and function tell you more than the picture does.

Minor arthritis. Joint changes happen naturally over time, and many people with mild arthritis stay symptom-free and active with proper exercise and movement. We explain how we think about it in Osteoarthritis: More Than Just Wear and Tear.

When Imaging Makes Things Seem Worse

In some cases, imaging can make a condition seem worse than it is. That can lead to unnecessary fear and cause people to avoid movement when staying active would actually help them recover. Misinterpreted imaging can also lead to treatments like injections or surgery when guided rehab may be the better first course.

A skilled provider considers both your imaging and your physical symptoms. Something looking abnormal on a scan doesn't mean it's responsible for your pain or that it needs immediate treatment. The human body is resilient and adaptable, and pain isn't always directly linked to structural changes you can see on a scan.

When You Might Need Imaging

If you're wondering whether you need a scan, this checklist can help. Imaging may be worth discussing with your provider when:

  • Your symptoms haven't improved after six or more weeks of rehab and movement.
  • Your pain is worsening for no clear reason.
  • You have serious warning signs, such as unexplained weight loss, severe weakness, or loss of bladder or bowel control.
  • You had a significant injury, like a fall or impact, and suspect a fracture or major structural damage.
  • You're considering surgery and need imaging to guide the decision.

If you have any serious warning signs, don't wait. Get evaluated promptly. This post is general education, not medical advice for your situation.

Questions to Ask If You've Already Had Imaging

  • Does this finding actually explain my symptoms?
  • Can you clarify how this affects my movement and daily activities?
  • Will this change my treatment plan, or is rehab still the best option?
  • Am I being advised to stop activity based solely on imaging, or is there a valid clinical reason?

How We Think About Imaging

At our sports rehab practice, we consider imaging one piece of the puzzle. It can be useful, but it doesn't always tell the full story. We help our clients understand their results in a way that makes sense, so they aren't alarmed by findings that may be incidental. If imaging suggests a different approach is needed, we adapt. In many cases, though, the best solution is still structured rehab focused on strength, mobility, and confidence in movement.

Your body is designed to heal and adapt. An MRI or X-ray shouldn't hold you back from doing what you love. If you've had imaging and are unsure what it means for your recovery, we're here to help you make sense of it.

Dr. Brett Poniros, DC, CSCS is the founder of Apollo Performance Chiropractic & Training in Pleasantville, NY.

Sources

  • Brinjikji W, Luetmer PH, Comstock B, et al. "Systematic Literature Review of Imaging Features of Spinal Degeneration in Asymptomatic Populations." American Journal of Neuroradiology. 2015;36(4):811-816. Read the review → — supports the disc degeneration and disc bulge prevalence figures under "What Scans Often Show in People Without Pain" (33 studies, 3,110 asymptomatic people)
  • Teunis T, Lubberts B, Reilly BT, Ring D. "A systematic review and pooled analysis of the prevalence of rotator cuff disease with increasing age." Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery. 2014;23(12):1913-1921. Read the review → — supports the rotator cuff prevalence claim under "What Scans Often Show in People Without Pain" (30 studies, 6,112 shoulders; abnormalities of all sizes, symptomatic and asymptomatic)